Thursday, May 24, 2007

"Can You Suggest Me A Book To Read?"

Being, perhaps, the one eyed in the town of blind, I get this asked of me a lot.

“Can you suggest me a book to read?”

I most certainly could, I would suggest that you first start with the classics. Maybe with Dickens, read Oliver Twist, Great Expectations, David Copperfield. Dickens, after all is not hard on the comprehension, might make a good start for anyone into reading. The trip, of course should ideally have started a long time ago. Being prepped up by Famous Fives, The Secret Sevens, The hardy Boys.

(To some I have been inclined to tersely suggest Wren & Martin. I have have been able to control that urge seeing that while that would one finger pointing at them, the rest would be showing my direction.)

Having started reading early is simply, having started well.

Because books, like events, are best read at a particular time, they have that much more significance; their impact is that much lasting.

Imagine for a moment, not having read Dickens in early teens? The character of Mr Pickwick is a whole lot different when you are fourteen of fifteen. Or not having read Tess of the D’Ubervilles, when puberty has just struck you? The romantic in you takes over, you wistfully look at the clouds and make up your mind you are going to marry a milkmaid when you grow up. Can you imagine not having read Two Men in a Boat in teens?

All of Dickens, Maupassant, Hardy, and Shakespeare must be read between the ages thirteen and twenty. Only then you can happily graduate to Thoreau, Sartre, Rand.

Only then you can, feast of everything else you can lay your hands on. Even the telephone book.

But alas, the person asking the question is not one who has, so to say, come up the ladder. He needs a book, which he probably will read it in a long protracted laborious way. He might understand what he has read or he might just sigh and feel happy that he read it.

I have flippantly answered that question many times. “Vatsyana” to a particularly prudish lady. “Gibbon”, “Hemingway”. I had the feeling that if they have not read so far they probably are going to read much.

There was a thought too, clawing at my mind. What if, there was one serious potential reader, a late blooming Tiger Woods of reading and I thwarted him by my flippancy or a wrong choice of book I gave him?

It sometimes is an agonizing thought; believe me. One I have never been able to decide. Should you start a newbie with bestsellers, racy fiction of Dan Brown, maybe go back a little to tried and tested ones by Harold Robbins, Arthur Hailey? Robbins’ A Stone for Danny Fisher bordered precariously on literary fiction.

Or would you rather take a risk and ask him to read Life of Pi, God of Small Things, Midnight’s Children, A Hundred Years of Solitude…

Must ask Tunku Halim, Eric Forbes, Sharon Bakar, Zafar Anjum this question.

6 comments:

Unknown said...

This is an interesting question and I too don't have the perfect answer. I've not come across a person who'd ask me this question. None of my colleagues read, and whatever friends and acquaintances I have, they are mostly book-aware people, even more well-read then me. But if someone asked me this question today, I'd direct him to the best 100 novels they must read in this magazine called Arena (Juen 2007 issue). He/she can read the summary of the novel there and start whatever catches her fancy. But, for a word of caution, I'd definitely not advice to begin with Marquez's One Hundred Years...

Good blog! Plz keep asking these interesting questions.

Cheers

Unknown said...

Dun mind the typos in my above post plz

Shakeel Abedi said...

Or Ulysses by Joyce, for that matter Zafar. But I would give an arm to see a newbie struggle with that one. :)

The Quiet Storm said...

I would recommend some light classics that would appeal to all ages. I read the Tale of Two Cities, White Fang, The Woman in White when I was 8 years old and I still find delight in rereading them sporadically.But no heavyweights though as that might put them off books for good.If they prefer non-fictional works then maybe you could suggest Paul Theroux or Bill Bryson.

Shakeel Abedi said...

TQS:

I did give one guy the Silverfish book 2, he never returned it. Perhaps he liked it too much or just did not hok him enough, never can tell.

I gave another Bryson's Short History of nearly Everything and she came back to return the book and ask for another.

:)

bibliobibuli said...

i've actually compiled a list of easy to read but satisfyingly good reads for my creative writing students who want to flood the world with their fiction but haven't actually got round to reading anything. it's a bit too long to post on my blog but i could put it somewhere else and link to it. hmmmm ...

i'm often not v. good with my recommendations. my book club members wanted to kill me after i recommended "never let me go" by kazuo ishiguro